The chart on Reception is wrong - he simply pasted in the 11/10/2000 R&R chart there (except for he did account for Rick's swapping in Joy Enriquez in the place of Mystikal's "Shake Ya Ass"). The actual countdown was thus:
Sure Shot: BBMak - Still on Your Side
40 -- Everclear - AM Radio
39 39 Joy Enriquez - Tell Me How You Feel
38 38 Usher - Pop Ya Collar
37 37 Lenny Kravitz - Again
36 36 Boyz II Men - Pass You By
35 35 Mandy Moore - Walk Me Home
34 28 The Wallflowers - Sleepwalker
33 SS Britney Spears - Stronger
32 33 Mikaila - So in Love With Two
31 32 Sisqo - Incomplete
30 29 SR-71 - Right Now
29 24 98 Degrees - Give Me Just One Night (Una Noche)
28 26 Everclear - Wonderful
27 30 Vitamin C - The Itch
26 34 Shaggy/RikRok - It Wasn't Me
25 27 Nine Days - If I Am
24 22 Baha Men - Who Let the Dogs Out
23 25 Faith Hill - The Way You Love Me
22 23 Evan and Jaron - Crazy For This Girl
21 19 Ruff Endz - No More
20 21 Dream - He Loves U Not
19 13 Destiny's Child - Jumpin', Jumpin'
18 14 Nelly - (Hot S**t) Country Grammar
17 18 Matchbox Twenty - If You're Gone
16 11 Christina Aguilera - Come on Over (All I Want is You)
15 17 Barenaked Ladies - Pinch Me
14 16 Kandi - Don't Think I'm Not
13 20 Destiny's Child - Independent Women Part 1
12 10 Vertical Horizon - You're a God
11 15 Debelah Morgan - Dance With Me
Request: Robbie Williams - Rock DJ
10 08 Ricky Martin - She Bangs
09 12 Mya - Case of the Ex (Whatcha Gonna Do)
08 09 Backstreet Boys - Shape of My Heart
07 06 soulDecision - Faded
06 07 Samantha Mumba - Gotta Tell You
05 04 Madonna - Music
04 05 'N Sync - This I Promise You
03 02 3 Doors Down - Kryptonite
02 03 Pink - Most Girls
01 01 Creed - With Arms Wide Open
In other words: Take the mentioned R&R chart, delete "Californication", swap Joy Enriquez in for Mystikal, swap Matchbox Twenty and Christina Aguilera - and there you go!
Much to my dismay, he played the same remix of "So in Love With Two" that AT40 did.
Notably, though, he played the clean edit of "Faded" - AT40 played the version that included a rapped bridge from Thrust.